# Independent review ledger

Five builders and five distinct reviewers ran in bounded waves. Each reviewer inspected rendered UI, source, tutorial and tests in three substantive passes. Failed findings are retained as history; final reports record corrections and explicit unverified boundaries.

| Demo | Builder / independent reviewer | Final record |
| --- | --- | --- |
| GIS Territory Explorer | gis_builder / gis_reviewer | [Pass 3](gis/pass3/report.json) |
| AI Integration Workbench | ai_builder / ai_reviewer | [Recovery recheck](ai/pass-3-recheck/report.json), [acceptance](ai/acceptance.json) |
| Vue Dealer Portal | portal_builder / portal_reviewer | [Pass 3](portal/pass3/report.json), [hosted CI supplement](portal/ci-supplement/report.json) |
| UX Workspace Studio | studio_builder / studio_reviewer | [Final pass 3](studio/pass-3-final/report.json), [status](studio/status.json) |
| Input Resilience | input_builder / input_reviewer | [Final label recheck](input/final-label/report.json), [acceptance](input/acceptance.json) |

See [all report paths](index.json). Public copies redact the local task-root prefix and private design-conversation URLs. Test fixtures are synthetic; no customer records or credentials are included.

The supporting international-architecture article received a separate bounded [integration review](architecture-integration/report.json) by the portal reviewer. It is an architecture explanation, not an additional working demo or an executed framework test.

The sixth story, Answer-first Gateway, came from its separately accepted track with three independent review passes. Its fifteen static files retain the exact handoff hashes and licenses. A focused [collection integration review](gateway-integration/report.json) checks the new card/navigation, standalone presentation and packaged boundary; it does not replace the upstream review or establish semantic generalization.

The portal's original final report correctly records MySQL as pending at that review time. The later CI supplement and `../../dealer-portal/evidence/ci-run.json` establish the executed MySQL/SQLite/browser result. Local tests and CI are not a production deployment or a live identity/provider test.